So Wrong on So Many Levels
So much in this publication is wrong on so many levels, it is hard to know where to begin.
How about the events it chronicles, which go back to May of this year. Why is it that only a select few events of the last five months made it into this "community newspaper?" Readers are informed about a Kite Flying Day in May and a senior wedding conveniently officiated by the mayor, but no mention is given to a host of significant other developments that took place during this time. Where is the mention of the most successful People's Organization for Progress-Board of Health annual Health Fair? Why is there nothing on the new Community Gardens Project, which had people all over town growing their own gardens for the first time? Why is former Councilman Lou Pichinson's name left off the list of governing body members but no article published telling people about his recent resignation?
This summer, Highland Park lost two of our community's most active participants--Vickie White, former school board member and president of the Central Jersey People's Organization for Progress, and Harvey Brudner, former chair of the Highland Park Centennial Commission and president of the Joyce Kilmer Centennial Commission. Yet nowhere in the Quarterly is there even a word about these losses, not to mention a tribute to two very dedicated public servants.
Then we have the issue of the professional public relations firm, Jaffe Communications, whose owner was recruited to write and edit borough publications because at a meeting of the New Jersey State League of Municipalities, he expressed his admiration for the way Mayor Frank came to power. He has been paid $2,500 for each issue of the Quarterly and is also paid separately for coordinating the Main Street newsletter.
Well, if a person is going to be paid to write, he or she should at least know how to write and how to proofread. If the Fall 2009 issue of the Quarterly is any indication, Jaffe can do neither. Here are some examples of the errors he displays in the Quarterly:
1. On the top right corner of Page 1, a photo is captioned, "Borrough officials, residents, and students gathered recently at the Highland Park Recreation Complex to celebrate the opening of a new turf field." No comment needed here.
2. The misleading article attributing Rite Aid's renovation to redevelopment suddenly quotes someone named "Nolan" on page 2 without introducing him or providing any background on him. It should have noted he is a former councilman and former member of the Redevelopment Agency.
3. On page 5, in an article mentioning Highland Park being designated a Fair Trade Town, the bottom paragraph in the third column states, "Members of the middle and high school band, orchestra, and choral recently sold Fair Trade coffee, tea, and chocolate as a fundraiser." Choral? Choral what? Isn't the correct word "choir" or "chorus?"
4. On page 5, in an article on three businesses celebrating their first anniversary in town, the bottom paragraph on the left reads, "She said Main Street organizations bring added resources to downtowns, such as small business training that provides tools to small business owners on how to market their business, facade upgrades, and signs, all of which attract customers." This is a very poorly worded sentence and is missing the necessary comma after "small business training," as this should be an incidental phrase set off by commas. Also, resources don't "provides"; they provide. A competent writer should know something about subject-verb agreement.
5. Our Superintendent of Schools apparently needs some lessons in comma usage as well. She says, "At the high school our focus remains on enriching our current programs to meet the special needs of our young people." Where is the comma required after a prepositional phrase begins a sentence? The statement should read, "At the high school, our focus remains..."
The Superintendent then continues with a run-on sentence, apparently not caught by Jaffe, reading, "Our fall sports teams have begun practicing on the turf field and we look forward to watching them compete in the new facility." Any English 101 student will tell you that turf field should be followed by a comma in front of the conjunction "and" to make this a correct sentence.
The Board of Education president does no better. "On behalf of the entire School Board I invite the community, not just the school community but the entire community, to participate in the many activities going on at our schools." How about inviting the Board of Education to a workshop explaining the basic concept that a sentence beginning with a phrase such as "On behalf of the entire School Board" should be followed by a comma?
Yet our esteemed Board president manages to put a comma where it doesn't belong in this sentence: "And, I highly recommend being in communication with other parents." Maybe some of those parents could tell her that the "and" starting her sentence should not have a comma following it.
There are far too many such errors in the Board president's report to chronicle them all. Here is one more: "An inspiring number of our graduates attend some of the most prodigious colleges and universities in the country." Prodigious means large in size. The word the Board president probably intended, which Jaffe never corrected, is "prestigious."
6. On page 12, an article announcing the Junior Cadet Police Academy states an application deadline of October 23. The Quarterly came out on October 28. What's wrong here?
Some may argue that minor grammar mistakes are insignificant, but given the amount of money being spent on this paper and the fact that the bulk of the errors occur in the schools' section, this very well can be considered a legitimate concern.
But the worst of all are the politically biased statements and subtle promotion of particular candidates and businesses. A week before the gubernatorial election, Mayor Frank tries to sneak in a promotional for Governor Corzine with this statement in the article on road improvements: "With these extra funds, thanks to Governor Corzine and Steve Dilts, we can fix more of our roads and make Highland Park an even better place to live."
Well, Corzine has been in office for four years and Frank for nine, yet many of our roads and sidewalks are in terrible condition.
Then there is the "Heal the World" Mayor's Message, which once again repeats her self-proclaimed designation of Highland Park as "New Jersey's first green community." How ironic this is in a paper with repeated references to the installation of artificial turf at the Highland Park Recreation Complex. Artificial turf, or plastic grass, contains lead chromate and involves safety hazards to users from exposure. In June 2008, the New Jersey Department of Health shut down six synthetic fields due to high lead levels. Artificial turf has a base layer of crumb rubber infill, which is made from used tires and is considered hazardous waste in several states.
When confronted with the less than green reality of the artificial turf, Mayor Frank out and out lied by saying the county required its use in the grant funding the field restoration. County officials subsequently contacted by reporters denied that any such requirement was attached to the grant.
Is Highland Park New Jersey's first green community just because the mayor says so, even if other towns are doing much more to actively promote green living? Decide for yourself. Some advice: read the Highland Park Mirror's series at http://www.highlandparkmirror.com/hpmfts.html on Highland Park's artificial turf before making the decision.
Mayor Frank says "we are proud of our leadership." Does that mean she is proud of herself? "You can be good and green too," says her condescending, third-grade level mayor's message. How can we be good and green? The answer is by patronizing a set of listed businesses, all owned by Frank supporters.
Among those businesses is no less than Centerpiece, which the mayor herself owns. She says, "Some more favorites are gorgeous red, purple, blue, green, or yellow recycled glass salad bowls at Centerpiece..." What this means is the mayor is spending taxpayer dollars to promote her own business in the borough newsletter. Is this even legal? Even if the answer is yes, it most certainly is in poor taste.
Finally, the Quarterly is not, as is falsely stated on page 3, "Highland Park's official newspaper." A town's "official" newspaper is the one it designates by ordinance to publish all of its advertising. In our case, that would be The Home News Tribune. Calling a government newspaper by this legal term is misleading and just plain wrong.
This issue of the Quarterly would truly be a "comedy of errors" if only our hard-earned dollars weren't funding it.